Publications
-
Read more
An obiter of the Québec Court of Appeal makes its way up to the Supreme Court of Canada
The facts The client, Station Lands Ltd. (“Station”) retained the general contractor Ledcor Construction Ltd. (“Ledcor”) to build the Epcor tower in Edmonton. As is customary, Station and Ledcor purchased a builders’ risk all-risk property insurance to cover property damage which may occur in the (…)
-
Read more
Wellington type motions seeking to order a CGL insurer to take up the defence of its insured
Recent case law which confirms the criteria applicable to Wellington motions and specifies the guidelines for the duty of an insurer to defend its insured. Admissibility or not of a Wellington motion against exclusions pertaining to the insured’s “products” and “work”, depending on the nature of the (…)
-
Read more
Nullity ab initio – misrepresentations during policy underwriting process
On August 18, 2016, the Honourable François Duprat, writing for the Superior Court of Québec, rendered judgment in the action brought by Jimmy Laporte (the “Plaintiff”) against his property insurer, Intact Insurance Company.1 The Court dismissed the Plaintiff’s action and declared the insurance (…)
-
Read more
“Peer-to-peer” insurance: a grassroots revolution?
After the hospitality sector, transportation of passengers and corporate financing, insurance could be the next sector to see its business model influenced by the sharing economy. In the past few years, numerous start-up companies have launched businesses in “peer-to-peer” (“P2P”) insurance on (…)
-
Read more
For rent… but mind the risks! Home Insurance in the age of the sharing economy
Many people could hardly imagine planning their vacations without considering online vacation rental community platforms. And those who have property available for use might find it just as difficult to resist the temptation to increase their revenues by advertising their room, apartment, house or (…)
-
Read more
Honesty of financial advisors and discretion of the Autorité des marchés financiers: the Québec Court of Appeal rules
In a decision issued last May 20,1 the Québec Court of Appeal affirmed a judgment2 of the Superior Court of Québec rendered on October 28, 2013, which dismissed the action in damages for more than $7 million brought by a former representative in insurance of persons and in group savings plan (…)
-
Read more
Fraud, nullity and compulsory professional liability insurance: the Québec Court of Appeal rules in
On May 16, 2016, the Québec Court of Appeal adjudicated1 on whether a professional liability insurer can plead the nullity of a policy based on misrepresentations or concealment of facts by the insured. This decision is of interest because it addresses the novel issue of whether a liability insurer (…)
-
Read more
The Court of Appeal: The liability of the life insurance broker is not limited to the framework of the contractual relationship
The facts of the Roy v. Lefebvre case On June 25, 2014, the Superior Court1 allowed the action of an insured against a life insurance broker and his firm. The context of the subscription of the insurance policy is somewhat unusual and deserves explanations. In 1992, the purchaser of an immovable (…)
-
Read more
$8 million awarded to a quadriplegic hockey player: the Court of Appeal confirms the Superior Court's decision
Last May 2, the Court of Appeal granted a motion to dismiss an appeal against a significant decision in the area of civil liability in the context of the practice of a sport.1 Decision at trial2 The facts in the case date back to October 3, 2010. A few seconds after the start of a hockey game (…)
-
Read more
Insurance contract terminology: the Court of Appeal clarifies the scope of the word ”building”
In insurance law, as well as in other areas of contract law, the precise definition and scope of the terminology used in a contract are very important since they have a direct effect on the obligations of the parties and, in the case under review, the scope of the insurance coverage. On February (…)
-
Read more
The Ontario Court of Appeal rules on the coverage exclusion of faulty workmanship by a contractor
On December 23, 2015, the Ontario Court of Appeal1 set aside a decision of the motion judge2 which had granted a motion for summary judgment brought by the insurer to dismiss a claim by its insured. Facts The insured had entered into an agreement with a contractor to restore the exterior cladding (…)
-
Read more
The Québec Court of Appeal rules on the duty to defend and the exclusion of liability assumed by contract
Last April 4, in the case of Aldo Group Inc. v. Chubb Insurance Company of Canada,1 the Court of Appeal ruled on the insurer’s duty to defend its insured and on the interpretation to be given to a clause excluding insurance coverage for liability contractually assumed by the insured. The decision (…)
-
Read more
Judge blows whistle to put a stop to checks from behind: $8,000,000 awarded to a quadriplegic hockey player
On February 1, 2016, the Superior Court of Québec rendered a significant decision in the area of civil liability in the context of the practice of a sport1. The judgment was widely reported in the media due, on the one hand, to the importance of the amount granted by the judge (8 million dollars) (…)